Your knee pain may be coming from the bone beneath the cartilage.
Subchondral BMAC places your own bone marrow concentrate directly into the stressed bone under the worn cartilage — not just into the joint space. For carefully selected Grade 2–3 knees, it may help delay knee replacement.
We don't start with an injection. We start by understanding your whole knee — and we will tell you honestly if replacement is the better choice.
Results from two published long-term studies of subchondral bone marrow concentrate (Hernigou et al., International Orthopaedics, 2021). These describe specific study groups — not a promise for every knee. Read what the studies show
Understanding the problem
Why does an arthritic knee hurt?
Most people think knee arthritis is only about cartilage "wearing out". But cartilage itself has almost no nerves — it cannot feel pain. The pain comes from the tissues around it, and one of the most important is the bone just beneath it.
🦴
Stressed bone under cartilage
The subchondral bone is alive, has a rich blood and nerve supply, and takes the load when cartilage thins. Overloaded bone can become painful.
🔥
Bone marrow lesions (BML)
Areas of "bone swelling" seen on MRI. They are linked with more pain and faster worsening of arthritis in many patients.
⚡
Tiny micro-cracks
Repeated overload can cause small stress injuries in the bone plate that supports the cartilage.
💧
Joint lining inflammation
An inflamed lining (synovium) causes swelling, warmth and morning stiffness.
↔️
Meniscus & alignment
A worn meniscus or bow-legs shift more weight onto one side of the knee.
💪
Weak muscles
Weak thigh and hip muscles mean the knee absorbs more shock with every step.
The right question is not only "how much cartilage is left?" — it is also "what is actually causing my pain?"
Diagnosis before treatment
An X-ray shows the gap. An MRI shows the story.
Both tests have a role. Not every patient needs an MRI — we advise one only when it will change your treatment plan.
Standing X-ray
Shape, space and alignment
How much joint space is left (your arthritis grade)
Leg alignment — bow-legs or knock-knees
Bone spurs and bone shape
Cheap, quick, done first for almost everyone
MRI
What's happening inside the bone
Bone marrow lesions — the target for this treatment
BMAC (Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate) is made from your own bone marrow. It contains your own healing cells, platelets and growth factors. "Subchondral" means we place it inside the bone just under the cartilage — right where the stress and pain are — instead of only injecting into the joint fluid.
Assessment & planning
Examination, standing X-rays and MRI to locate the stressed bone areas and confirm you are a suitable candidate.
Bone marrow collection
A small amount of marrow is drawn from the back of your hip bone (pelvis) under anaesthesia. No cut or stitches — just a needle puncture.
Concentration
The marrow is processed in a special closed system to concentrate the healing cells. This is done right there, in the same session.
Targeted placement
Under live X-ray (C-arm) guidance, the concentrate is placed into the lesion area in the bone below the cartilage. Part of it is usually also given into the joint.
Rehab & follow-up
A structured exercise programme and review visits to track pain, walking and strength.
Regular joint injection
Subchondral BMAC
Goes into the joint fluid only
Goes into the bone under the cartilage + joint
Treats the joint lining & surface
Targets the stressed bone seen on MRI
Done in OPD
Done in operation theatre, usually same-day discharge
Often repeated
Usually a single procedure
—
Both knees can be treated in one session
What this treatment is not: it does not instantly regrow a new cartilage, it is not a cure for arthritis, and it does not work the same in every knee. It is one part of a plan that also includes weight management, strengthening and follow-up.
The research
Two long-term studies. Real numbers.
Both studies were published by Prof. Philippe Hernigou and colleagues (France) in International Orthopaedics. We show the actual numbers so you can judge for yourself.
Study 1 · Randomised
Bone injection vs joint injection
60 patients with arthritis in both knees. One knee got BMAC into the bone under the cartilage; the other knee got the same dose into the joint only.
Subchondral (bone)80% avoided replacement
Joint injection only30% avoided replacement
12 of 60 bone-treated knees needed replacement, compared with 42 of 60 joint-injected knees, over about 15 years.
Hernigou P, Bouthors C, Bastard C, et al. Int Orthop 2021;45:391–399 · PubMed 32617651 ↗
Study 2 · Randomised
BMAC vs knee replacement in the other knee
140 patients who were due for replacement in both knees. One knee got a replacement; the other got subchondral BMAC.
BMAC knees82% still without replacement
115 of 140 BMAC-treated knees had not needed replacement at about 15 years. In the 25 knees that did, it happened on average around 10 years later. Bone lesions shrank on MRI over 2 years; larger lesions that stayed were linked with later replacement.
Hernigou P, Delambre J, Quiennec S, Poignard A. Int Orthop 2021;45:365–373 · PubMed 32322943 ↗
✓ What these studies support
Subchondral BMAC is a reasonable option to consider in selected patients who want to delay knee replacement — and placing it in the bone appeared to work better than injecting the same dose into the joint only.
! What they do not prove
They do not guarantee 15 years of pain relief for you, and they come from one expert team. Your result will depend on your arthritis grade, lesion size, alignment, weight and rehab.
Is it right for you?
One treatment does not fit every knee.
We decide together, based on your symptoms, examination, X-ray, MRI, general health and your goals.
You may be a good candidate if…
You have Grade 2–3 knee arthritis
Knee pain continues despite medicines, physiotherapy and weight control
Your MRI shows bone marrow lesions / bone stress under the cartilage
You want to delay or avoid knee replacement
You are ready to follow a strengthening and rehab plan
Another treatment may suit you better if…
Grade 4 "bone-on-bone" arthritis or collapse of the joint
Major bow-leg / knock-knee deformity that needs correction
Active infection, uncontrolled diabetes or a blood disorder
A badly unstable knee or active inflammatory arthritis needing separate treatment
1
Early
Slight roughening. Occasional pain.
Exercise · lifestyle
2
Mild
Cartilage thinning, pain with activity.
Suitable
3
Moderate
Clear narrowing, daily pain, stairs difficult.
Suitable
4
Severe
Bone-on-bone, pain at rest, deformity.
Knee replacement
📝
Not sure which grade you are?
Take our free 2-minute Knee Self-Assessment. Answer simple questions about pain, stiffness, walking and stairs — and get an idea of your arthritis stage before your consultation.
A minimally invasive procedure — not a knee replacement. Details vary from person to person.
1
Before
Consultation
Examination, X-ray and MRI review, blood tests and fitness check. We explain all options — including replacement — and take your consent.
2
Procedure day
Operation theatre
Sterile conditions, anaesthesia, marrow collection from the hip bone, and X-ray-guided placement into the knee. Takes about 1–1.5 hours.
3
First weeks
Protected walking
Usually home the same day. Some soreness in the knee and hip is normal. You may use a walker or crutches for a short period as advised.
4
Rebuild
Weeks to months
Guided exercises to strengthen your thigh, hip and core. Review visits to track pain, walking and function.
Low downtime is not zero downtime. Some patients need protected weight-bearing for a few weeks. We do not promise instant relief — we give you a realistic plan.
Free rehab guide
The treatment is one day. Protecting your knee is a process.
A simple phase-wise exercise framework. Tap a phase to see the exercises.
Protect & activate
Goal: keep blood flowing, wake up the thigh muscle, gentle movement.
Exercise
Sets × reps
Ankle pumps
3 × 20
Static quadriceps (press knee down)
3 × 15, hold 5 sec
Glute squeezes
3 × 15, hold 5 sec
Heel slides (comfortable range)
2 × 10–15
Straight leg raise*
2 × 10
*Only if you can keep the knee fully straight while lifting.
Control
Goal: full bending and straightening, walking pattern, hip strength.
Exercise
Sets × reps
Short-arc quads (roll under knee)
3 × 12
Side-lying hip abduction
3 × 12
Bridges
3 × 10
Stationary cycle, no resistance (if cleared)
10 min
Weight shifting with support
2 × 10
Foundation
Goal: start standing strength and balance once full weight is allowed.
Exercise
Sets × reps
Mini squats (chair behind you)
3 × 10
Calf raises
3 × 15
Wall sit, shallow
3 × 20 sec
Single-leg balance with support
3 × 20 sec
Cycling, light resistance
15 min
Strength
Goal: build thigh and hip strength for stairs and longer walks.
Exercise
Sets × reps
Sit-to-stand from chair
3 × 12
Step-ups (low step)
3 × 10 each leg
Resistance band side-walks
3 × 10 steps
Leg press / knee extension (light, in gym)
3 × 12
Brisk walking on flat ground
20–30 min
Return to life
Goal: long-term knee care habits — this phase never really ends.
Habit
How often
Strength routine (thigh, hip, core)
3 days/week
Walking, cycling or swimming
Most days
Weight control — every kg lost reduces knee load
Ongoing
Avoid deep squatting / floor sitting on bad days
As needed
Review with Dr. Sumit
As scheduled
Your own doctor's instructions come first. Weight-bearing limits and progression depend on lesion size, bone quality and how your knee responds. Stop and call us for marked swelling, fever, increasing redness, calf pain or breathlessness.
Improvement is gradual and varies from person to person. Pain relief is not guaranteed.
Days–weeks
Settling
Procedure soreness in the knee and hip settles. Follow the walking and loading advice.
6–12 weeks
First review
We check pain, swelling, walking and how your exercises are progressing.
3–6 months
Building function
Strength, walking distance and daily activities usually keep improving.
Long term
Monitoring
Regular check-ups. Repeat imaging only when it will help a decision.
DABRMAMERICAN BOARD OF REGENERATIVE MEDICINE
Why Dr. Sumit Dubewar?
Dr. Sumit Dubewar is an orthopaedic surgeon in Secunderabad with 10+ years of experience in both regenerative orthopaedics and joint replacement — including robotic knee replacement. He holds the DABRM (Diplomate, American Board of Regenerative Medicine), one of very few orthopaedic surgeons in India with this US certification.
Because he performs both BMAC and knee replacement, your advice is not biased towards one treatment. If replacement is the better choice for your knee, you will be told so clearly.
Will one injection avoid knee replacement for 10–15 years?
There is no personal guarantee. In one study, 82% of treated knees had not needed replacement at about 15 years — but that was a specific group treated by one expert team. Your result depends on your grade, lesion size, alignment, weight and how well you follow rehab.
Is this the same as PRP?
No. PRP is made from your blood and injected into the joint. BMAC is made from your bone marrow and contains your own healing cells, platelets and growth factors. In this treatment it is placed into the bone under the cartilage, which a regular PRP injection does not reach.
Do I need an MRI?
A standing X-ray and examination come first. For this particular treatment, an MRI is usually needed to find the bone marrow lesions we are targeting. If you already have one, send it to us.
Is it painful? Will I be awake?
The procedure is done under anaesthesia, so you will not feel it during the procedure. Afterwards, some soreness in the knee and at the hip bone is common for a few days and is managed with simple painkillers and ice.
Will I need to stay in hospital?
Most patients go home the same day. You may need a walker or crutches for a short period, depending on how much bone was treated.
Can both knees be done together?
Yes. Since BMAC comes from your own bone marrow, both knees can usually be treated in the same session if both need it.
Is it safe? What are the risks?
It uses your own cells, so there is no risk of rejection. Possible risks include temporary pain and swelling, bruising at the hip bone, and rarely infection. We discuss all risks in detail before consent.
What if it doesn't work for me?
Having BMAC does not stop you from having a knee replacement later if needed. We will monitor you and discuss the next step honestly if your knee does not improve as expected.
Find out if your knee is eligible — free.
Fill this 1-minute form. Our team will review your details, and WhatsApp will open so you can send your MRI / X-ray for a free review by Dr. Sumit.
A clear conversationYour symptoms, goals and reports reviewed properly.
No pressure to have an injectionYou'll hear all options, including replacement.
A real rehab planTreatment comes with exercises and follow-up.
Your name, number and answers are shared only with our clinic team so we can contact you. MRI / X-ray reports are sent only through WhatsApp — never uploaded to this website. Not for emergencies.
This page is for patient education and is not personal medical advice. Published study percentages describe specific study groups and are not a guarantee of individual results. Not every patient is a candidate. Risks, alternatives and expected outcomes will be discussed in person during consultation. See our disclaimer.